The median home value in Sag Harbor, NY is $2,535,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $490,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Sag Harbor, NY is $2,535,000.
Approximately 36.7% of Sag Harbor homes are owned,
compared to 11.3% rented, while
51.8% are vacant.
Sag Harbor real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Sag Harbor real estate agent to arrange a tour today! Learn more about Sag Harbor.
Conveniently located in Sag Harbor Village and sited on 0.18 acres, this three-bedroom two-bath home offers lots of opportunities with room for a pool. The home has a living room, an eat-in kitchen with all appliances, a primary bedroom, two guest bedrooms, and two bathrooms. There is a finished lower level with a den, storage, and laundry, plus a one-car attached garage. The outside features a lovely yard with plenty of areas to entertain or expand, a large spacious deck with seating an outside shower, a shed plus room for a pool. Located in Sag Harbor Village and near iconic shopping, dining, waterfront, and Bay beaches.
Welcome to 1224 Brick Kiln, a stunning single-family residence nestled in the heart of Sag Harbor, NY. This luxurious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom estate is situated on a breathtaking 6.2-acre private compound, offering serenity and seclusion while remaining just minutes from the vibrant Sag Harbor Main Street and picturesque Mashashimuet Park. As you approach the residence, you enter onto a winding circular driveway with ample space for parking along with EV home-supercharge set up. Step inside the double entrance doors and marvel at the captivating three-story cantilevered ceiling living room, featuring a sleek slate fireplace and elegant five-columned design. The spacious and sophisticated floor plan spans approximately 5,000+ sq.ft, including the lower level which is ready to be finished to your liking. Entertain in style with the beautiful bricked terrace, heated pool, and newly laid Har-Tru tennis court, accessible through the living room or master suite's four French doors. The large country kitchen boasts all-new stainless-steel appliances, perfect for creating culinary masterpieces. The impressive master bedroom suite offers a marble bath, separate shower stall, and Jacuzzi tub, providing the ultimate sanctuary for rest and rejuvenation. Enjoy picturesque sunsets over your very own wooded six+ acres personal reserve, providing an unmatched sense of privacy and tranquility. With its central location to parks, shopping, harbor, and beaches. Don't miss the opportunity to call this spectacular Sag Harbor estate your new home.
Beautiful home set 75' back from the road in a private and serene setting. Newly renovated 2nd floor bathroom. Outdoor shower. Detached garage. Irrigation System. Room for pool.
Imagine being just moments away from one of the East End's most popular villages, yet in tranquility. Stately traditional family home with classic front porch in the coveted waterfront community of Bay Haven in North Haven, with two private bay beaches and community mooring field. Enjoy Sag Harbor schools and the close proximity to Sag Harbor Village, marinas, and beaches. Extra features, such as the enclosed porch and sitting sunroom off the primary bedroom make this a special offering.
Sleek, modern new construction with acres of privacy. Ready to Move in! Indulge in the epitome of luxury living with this sleek and modern custom-built masterpiece. Boasting a sprawling 8,635 sq. ft., this stunning home features 8 bedrooms, 7 full baths, and 3 half baths, all situated on a private 4.8-acre estate. Enter through the elegant foyer to discover an open floor plan, perfect for entertaining guests and hosting lavish gatherings. The professional designer kitchen is a chef's dream, while the great room, living room, and dining room exude sophistication and style. This home is designed for entertainment, offering a theater, recreation room, gym, covered patios, pergola, outdoor fireplace, salt water Gunite pool, and jacuzzi. The perfect blend of indoor and outdoor living, you'll relish the opportunity to enjoy the outdoors all year round. The early home buyer has the opportunity to customize this home to their unique lifestyle, creating a truly one-of-a-kind living experience. Don't miss out on the chance to make this luxurious sanctuary your own.
Renovated Classic in Sag Harbor Village This is an exquisitely renovated traditional home located in Sag Harbor Village near Main Street, restaurants, shops, Long Wharf and many marinas. The uncommonly large 2/3 +/- acre lot features four separate buildings and a 45' salt water gunite pool. The buildings include a 1920s house, an historic pool house which has an art studio, a one car garage with storage space and a garden shed. Originally built in the 1920s, the home has kept its charm through expansion and numerous updates. The four-bedroom, three-bathroom light-filled home has an open kitchen/dining/living room floorplan with a wood burning fireplace and adjoining den. The luxurious first floor primary suite has a 13 foot trayed ceiling, two walk-in closets, a windowed office/sunroom, a spacious marble bathroom and a brick patio with a verdant wisteria-covered pergola. Sunny porches and decks embrace the first floor living area. The second floor has an additional two bedrooms and a full bath with a free-standing soaking tub and a separate shower. The lower level provides recreation and ample storage spaces. The large yard is filled with specimen trees including crepe myrtle, magnolia, cherry and dogwood trees, to name a few, as well as many flower gardens. The enchanting pool house/art studio is an original 1,156 +/- sq foot Freight House from the long defunct Sag Harbor-Bridgehampton train spur.
Discover the quintessential Sag Harbor lifestyle in this spacious and meticulously maintained home, ideally situated in the coveted Historic District. Just a short distance away from Main Street and Haven's Beach, 20 Hamilton Street offers the perfect blend of classic charm and modern convenience. The open floor plan, perfect for entertainment, seamlessly connects the living room, dining room, and the eat-in kitchen, featuring top-of-the-line appliances like a Jenn-Air 6-burner gas stove, Sub-Zero fridge, U-Line wine fridge, Avalon bottle-less water cooler, and a Bosch dishwasher. This classic home boasts 4 bedrooms including a generously sized en-suite primary bedroom on the first floor. In addition there's a versatile office/den and a welcoming media room, providing different ambiances for the whole family. Three full baths complete the indoor layout. Outside, the beautifully landscaped backyard with a spacious patio deck overlooking the heated pool (34'x14') offers your own private oasis. In addition, the attached one-car garage with an electric car charger provides modern convenience. With its classic charm and serene location on a quiet street, this Sag Harbor treasure offers a lifestyle that's both timeless and convenient.
Seize the chance to become the proud owner of brand new construction in Sag Harbor! Experience the epitome of modern living with an open floor plan that perfectly complements today's lifestyle. This exquisite home offers four bedrooms and three and a half baths, providing ample space for comfortable living. Situated near the charming Sag Harbor Village and offering mooring rights, this property blends convenience and luxury seamlessly. Don't miss out on this exceptional opportunity!
Sag Harbor Waterfront! Welcome to 43 Harbor Drive, located in Sag Harbor's prestigious waterfront community of Bay Point. The property is perfectly sited on Sag Harbor Cove and features a 3,300+/- sf modern home with pool and deep-water dock. The home is built with steel construction, sound proofing, no-maintenance exterior, and lush landscaping. This 4-bedroom, 4-bath home was completed in 2019 and exemplifies state of the art contemporary design. The balance of aesthetics and function enhances the value and desirability of the waterfront location. The open floor plan accentuates gorgeous water views from nearly every room. The gourmet kitchen features top appointments including Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances and Corian countertops. The large windows stream abundant sunlight and showcase fabulous water views from the kitchen, dining and living areas. The living room features a wood-burning fireplace and opens onto an exterior bluestone terrace. The first floor offers 2 bedrooms with exterior access and direct water views. Upstairs, the primary suite, with private outdoor terrace, has stunning panoramic views of the Cove, and a chic master bath with imported hand laid Italian tile. The third level offers a rooftop deck and lounge complete with gas fire pit and incomparable sunset views of Sag Harbor. Enjoy your 16'x 9' heated gunite pool, 4x4 jacuzzi, outdoor shower and no-maintenance astro turf backyard. The house features Green Logic 32 triple-XL solar panels to maintain efficient low cost energy. This home is a boater's dream featuring a deep-water dock that accommodates a 40+/- ft boat even at low tide. The desirable location is minutes from Long Beach for swimming and the best sunset views in the Hamptons. Bay Point is in Sag Harbor school district, and just minutes from Sag Harbor village. Living in the Hamptons is all about the water. This waterfront home is a slice of paradise that is priced to sell.
Escape to a charming 3 bed, 2 bath Sag Harbor rental for an off-season retreat. Open living and dining area, fully equipped kitchen, and cozy bedrooms offer comfort and relaxation. Modern amenities, including a fireplace, ensure a cozy stay. Explore the historic village's boutiques and dine in its renowned restaurants. Take leisurely strolls by the waterfront Located 1 mile from Foster Memorial Beach (Long Beach) and 1/2 mile from Sag Harbor Village. Experience Sag Harbor's allure in this inviting rental.
Sag Harbor Compound in Waterfront Community - This compound is situated on .76 of an acre in the Turtle Cove waterfront community, with its private beach and mooring rights. The main house features an updated kitchen, living room with fireplace, formal dining room, and enclosed porch, as well as 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and a separately-accessed studio apartment. Outside are a gunite pool, basketball court, and a privately-located studio, complete with kitchenette, full bath, loft and a designated parking area. There's a farmstand nearby, and the beach to enjoy - all just minutes from Sag Harbor Village.
Opportunity at 105 Merchants Path. Building permits in place. A private 3.4 acres moments to both Sag Harbor and East Hampton Villages. Enjoy all the area has to offer. 7 bedrooms, 7.5 baths. Dramatic 25 foot vaulted ceilings and open great room. Gourmet Chef's kitchen. First floor primary suite with fireplace, spa bath, WIC, and private sitting room/home office. Finished lower level planned with large rec space, wellness center, and gym. Theater room and an additional ensuite bedroom are complete. Out back a proposed 50ft heated Gunite pool, tennis court. Make it your own.
Nestled in the heart of Sag Harbor's coveted Historical district, this pristine residence offers a blend of charm and modern comfort. Situated just a short distance away from the vibrant town center and the highly sought-after Havens Beach, this property provides an idyllic lifestyle in one of the Hamptons' most cherished enclaves. As you approach the front entrance, a covered screen porch welcomes you into a world of sophistication and elegance. The first floor presents a thoughtful layout that seamlessly integrates various living spaces. The formal living room, with its wood-burning fireplace, exudes a cozy ambiance that's perfect for gatherings, while an expansive den/library provides ample space for relaxation or work. The state-of-the-art eat-in-kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting top-of-the-line appliances, including a Viking stove, Miele dishwasher and a Subzero refrigerator. Sliding doors flood the space with light and open to the backyard, making it an ideal setting for entertaining. A chic designer powder room completes the home's public spaces. The ground floor en-suite primary bedroom is a true retreat, featuring a sliding door that leads directly to the serene backyard, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor connection. Moving to the second floor, 2 generous bedrooms await, each offering comfort and character. A windowed full bath on this level ensures convenience for all occupants. A fully-finished basement, complete with laundry, provides ample storage space. The beautifully landscaped backyard, surrounded by bamboo trees, creates a serene and zen-like atmosphere. A lovely wooden deck provides a perfect spot for outdoor lounging, while an outdoor shower and a brick patio add to the functionality and charm of the space. Mature trees dot the property, adding natural beauty and shade to the landscape. Tucked away on a tranquil street, this residence offers the perfect balance of privacy and proximity to Sag Harbor's vibrant scene. This property is an exceptional opportunity for those seeking the quintessential Hamptons lifestyle.
Welcome to 41 Wickatuck Drive; just a block to Long Beach and minutes drive to Sag Harbor Village!! This stylish beach bungalow has been completely reimagined for the ease of today's living with a very privately situated pool area and several outdoor entertaining areas. Newly renovated, this home features an all-new kitchen with stainless steel appliances and remodeled bathroom and detached garage. Expansion plans include a 4 bedroom, 4 1/2 bath home. Currently offering two bedrooms one full bath, one half bath with open kitchen, living and dining floor plan, hardwood floors throughout and a wood burning fireplace. Access from the first floor, the lower level has a laundry area and half bath. Bilco doors lead to the outdoor entertaining areas, pool and outdoor shower. New and mature landscaping nestle this turn-key beach cottage.
Sag Harbor Contemporary First time year around rental, a rare find! Beautiful designer's own home on a quiet street in Sag Harbor Village. Very close to village schools, parks, marinas, restaurants, beaches and shopping. You will enjoy the salt water pool, exterior sound system, outdoor shower, vegetable garden all in this secluded, fenced in back yard oasis. For more summer fun, take a short drive to East Hampton Ocean beaches for surfing, picnics, swimming on the pristine Hamptons sandy beaches. Very cosey home with wood burning fireplace, chef's kitchen, 2 car garage, great primary bedroom, plenty of light streaming from all sides. Spend a beautiful year in this beautiful home in Sag Harbor.
Set on a quiet village street just minutes from the world-class shops, restaurants and waterfronts of Sag Harbor lies this newly renovated 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home. Every detail of the the house has been executed to exacting specifications and highest quality: Ornare designed kitchen, Newport Brass fixtures, Thermador appliances, and white oak flooring. Outside the freshly designed landscape now has a heated, gunite, salt water pool, specimen plantings and large grass area. A new nitrogen reduction septic system has also been installed. This is a truly special property not to be missed.
Location, Location, Location! A REWARDING BEACH ESCAPE PEACEFULLY SITUATED: Luxurious and upgraded, this 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom home of 2200 sq. ft. rests on a lot of .19 acres (per county) on a peaceful corner lot in a private beach neighborhood. Richly-appointed spaces include large gathering area, a nicely appointed kitchen, dining area, a master suite, and multiple patio areas. Contemporary amenities include electric LED lit fireplace. The backyard includes a patio area in private, verdant surroundings. You'll appreciate the short drive or walk to the Village Main Street. A Swimming pool was recently approved by both the Architectural Review Board and Zoning Board of Appeals". Seller will not build the pool, new buyer have to build the pool.
The all season house you've always dreamed about. Renovated and move-in ready, there are approved plans with permits in place to add an additional room and two bathrooms. Currently there's a living room with fireplace, eat-in kitchen and large dining/sitting area with heated flooring overlooking the al fresco entertainment areas, lush landscaping, lawn, sparkly new heated gunite pool and outdoor shower. Windows are new and skylights in living room and kitchen are electric, pleasantly flooding the house with light. Move right in and enjoy while you decide if you want to expand and renovate further. Minutes to the beach, marinas and Sag Harbor Village. Oh, and there's even a glimpse of the bay as you walk out the front door. This is the one and you can be in immediately!
Beautiful, light filled, 3BR/2Bath newly renovated modern ranch with high end finishes. Open concept living space with abundant skylights and granite counters, center island, and SS appliances. Hard wood floors throughout. Heated in-ground 20x40 saltwater pool, eucalyptus sauna, outdoor shower, fenced in backyard with privacy. EV charger and parking for 3 cars. The beach is 1/2 mile away or minutes to the village. Suitable for year-round or seasonal living. Established rental record. Can be bought with furniture.
New Sag Harbor Rental. First Time on the Market, this 4 Bedroom, 4.5 bath home in Sag Harbor is newly constructed and ready for summer in the Hamptons. The 2,153+/- sf home features an open concept living space, fireplace, spacious primary ensuite, chef's kitchen with a dining area, stainless steel appliances, and sliding glass doors leading to the patio which overlooks the heated gunite pool and manicured grounds. The second-floor features 3 ensuite bedrooms and a sitting area. The lower level with separate egress hosts a lounge area with pool table, laundry, and full bath. Close to the heart of Sag Harbor Village and moments away from a private beach, this Hamptons summer rental is not to be missed.
Build your dream home in this pristine 2.82-acre parcel on a quiet cul-de-sac, in the desirable North Haven Point Association. The unimproved parcel of land is available for purchase as is or owner/builder will work with buyer to customize a land/build package. The North Haven Point Association is a wonderful community and offer its residents community tennis, private beach rights, and easy access to the Village of Sag Harbor and Shelter Island.
Spacious and bright mid-century ranch is ready for your renovation/expansion, or take advantage of this large 1+ acre property to build your dream 4500+ SF home. This well maintained 1850 square foot home, with an attached garage and full, finished walk out basement, is sited on a sprawling and cleared south-facing 1.13-acre lot. Inside you'll find four bedrooms, three full baths, a living and dining room with a brick fireplace, plus a large kitchen. The airy and classic open floorplan offers numerous design/expansion options. Its large deck, overlooking the spacious and private backyard, is great for entertaining and relaxing. 871 Brick Kiln Road is perfectly located less than a mile from Sag Harbor Village, near marinas/beaches, and is directly across the road from the 113 acre Mulvihill hiking reserve. Bridgehampton and Southampton are close-by. Plans drawn and approvals in process for 5000 SF property plus pool.
