The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,187,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $490,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $1,187,500.
Approximately 28.5% of Shelter Island homes are owned,
compared to 7% rented, while
64% are vacant.
Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today! Learn more about Shelter Island.
Nestled in the tranquil wooded haven of Hay Beach is this exceptional 3-bedroom 3-bath modern ranch. Upon entering, you are welcomed by an open floor plan that effortlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas. These are rounded off by top-of-the-line appliances from Bosch, Liebherr, and Viking, all set within Levante wood cabinetry and granite countertops. Step outside and be captivated by the breathtaking gardens surrounding the inground pool and hot tub. Included on the expansive patio is a full outdoor kitchen to complete your escape from the stresses of everyday life. This renovated turnkey oasis awaits you.
This charming 1953 waterfront Cottage is a true gem, offering breathtaking water views and sunsets from most rooms and the yard. Nestled on a .46-acre property and graced by southwest prevailing breezes. The home retains its original charm with wood-paneled walls, vaulted ceilings featuring exposed trusses, and oak floors throughout. The open floor plan and cozy wood-burning fireplace in the living room create an inviting space for relaxation and gatherings. Outdoor entertaining is a delight on the deck and covered porch, both easily accessible from the main living areas. Please note, this property is being sold "As Is". It does not have a heating system, and the fuel tank has been removed from the partial basement. Despite these factors, this Cottage presents an incredible opportunity to own a slice of waterfront paradise or to bring your vision to life with some updates or renovations.
Luxurious Village of Dering Harbor. Ready to build 4450 sf home, 2 car garage, pool and patio situated on pristine wooded 3.1 acres overlooking private golf course. Additional 1 acre preserved land between the property and Manhanset Road. Private road on a cul-de-sac. Architectural drawings include site plan, floor plans, elevations and specification list. Suffolk County Department of Health Services permit good until 2026. Site survey included.
Once in a lifetime opportunity to create your very own Private Compound on this Beautiful 4 Acre Property on sought-after Shelter Island! The land is partially cleared and level, ready for you to put your dreams into action! There is a conservation easement on 2 of the 4 Acres. The rear of the property backs up to a 24 Acre Preserve with maintained, groomed and marked hiking trails, ensuring forever privacy, beauty and tranquility! Hiking, Biking, and various Outdoor Recreational activities are available right outside your front door! Wildlife includes Whitetail Deer, Bald Eagles, Turkeys, Fox, Chipmunks and Songbirds galore! Mashomack Preserve, a 2,039 Acre Coastal Nature Reserve on an Island with marshes, forest & creeks, is only a short distance away, where you can truly unwind and discover Paradise!
Lovely Hay Beach Home with Pool Nicely appointed seasonal 4 bedrooms, 3 bath home with inground 9' diving pool awaiting your arrival. Spacious home on a shy acre with a deck and patio for outdoor entertaining. Close to beaches, shopping, and ferries. Come to Shelter Island this summer and enjoy nature. Great home for all! A firepit, gazebo, chairs, and lounges are included. Well-behaved dog-friendly home.
Hot off the press! This absolutely gorgeous custom-built home is finished and ready to enjoy for the season! 4 spacious bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, heated 16x32 gunite pool, mahogany decks - an amazing open floor plan. A true showstopper of a chef's kitchen with GE Cafe series appliances will be the envy of all! Two laundry rooms, living room with a gas fireplace, an office or a gym and a full basement with an egress window. Near Crescent Beach, The Pridwin, Sunset Beach, The Perlman Summer Music Program. Incredible attention to detail - this is a must see! Please call for a private appointment!
This home is nestled in the Montclair Colony area, a peninsula community between West Neck and Menantic Creeks. This quiet area is adorned by acres of walkable preserved lands and easy access to creeks, a marina, and restaurants. Features of this beautiful home include a heated in-ground pool, a large great room with a propane fireplace, a living room with a wood stove, an office area, a powder room, a dining room, an eat-in kitchen, and a master bedroom with ensuite bathroom and walk-in closets. Upstairs are 2 large bedrooms with abundant storage, a cedar closet, and a very large full bath. Outside is a semi-enclosed shower (an island necessity) A breezeway connects the home to the 2-car garage This home was purposefully built to look toward the western sky to witness the brilliant sunsets. Just a wonderful year-round home or seasonal rental.
Look no further for your island getaway than this beautiful property adjacent to public beach Reel Point. All on a single level, it features views of Orient Point, Gardiners Bay, and Mashomack Preserve, all the way to Easthampton out to Montauk! An energy star construction, it has a tankless water heater, 3500 sqft of ipe hardwood decking on the waterside, and surrounding the gunite pool, for effortless hosting. Enjoy the unparalleled views from the main living area, with an open floor plan allowing for seamless transitions between spaces. Down the hall are the bedrooms, providing privacy, seclusion, and separation of activities. This house will be a perfect home for however long you might desire it!
Enjoy all The Hamptons have to offer in this newly recreated waterfront home in the heart of West Neck Harbor! Complete with a boat and complimentary captain at the end of your private dock. Every detail was masterfully thought through by a leading design team. The floor plan offers a first-floor primary suite, four additional private guest bedrooms with two gracious common living spaces, a dining area and adjacent guest cottage. Every room was uniquely designed, each having endless water views of West Neck Harbor. Outdoor living includes a heated, salt water, gunite pool with spa, accompanied by a sauna and outdoor shower. From the patio, take a walk down the waterfront deck to watch the stunning sunset. Soak in every minute of summer at this waterfront retreat.
